Votes for Sheik Edit
- User:Speedchuck Shiek could beat Tetra to a pulp!!
- XXXXX 19:39, 7 May 2008 (UTC) I might change later, but right now Sheik gets the vote.
- Hero of Time 87 20:23, 7 May 2008 (UTC) Sheik, for many obvious reasons: 1) Sheik is in reality the original Princess Zelda, and by extension, one of the most powerful incarnations of her in Zelda history; 2) Sheik has FAR more martial arts abilities than Tetra (although Tetra remains a formidable opponent, especially with a bow and arrow); 3) Sheik possesses the full Triforce of Wisdom, whereas Tetra only possessed a fragment of it for quite some time, until she assumed her identity as Zelda (and even then, it's unknown whether or not she still possesses it at the end of TWW); 4) Sheik is known to be a great fighter, even on grounds with the Hero of Time himself, something that can't really be said for Tetra. All in all, Sheik is a FAR more powerful incarnation of Zelda than Tetra really, and the original Zelda is more likely to be more powerful than one that is further down the bloodline (the Seven Maidens even noted that their powers had thinned across time). Sheik would win this battle hands down though.
- Klaros sheik is better by far after all, sheik manages to avoid capture for 7years and consider her skill with deku nuts and her agility.
- LadyNorbert 23:14, 7 May 2008 (UTC) I've never played either of the Zelda games with these characters; however, I have played SSBB, and Sheik is an amazing character in there. Also, I think Tetra is just sort of weird-looking.
- shiek is a teenage ninja and tetra is a kid pirate *cough* avatar *cough* --Power courage wisdom and time 00:55, 8 May 2008 (UTC)
- Pirate vs. Ninja. No contest. Sheik. Murchadah 02:03, 8 May 2008 (UTC)
- User:mr.popo Sheik is stronger than tetra because he have ninja's abilities
- AuronKaizer: Although Sheik creeps me out and brings back painful memories of a prank someone pulled on me involving Futanari (don't Google it if you want to keep your sanity), Sheik had lots of great dialogue in Ocarina of Time. Tetra could be overbearingly annoying at times, and even spent an entire game encased in stone, so this is pretty much a no-brainer. Jeez, are we ever gonna get an even match around here? >.< 17:18, 8 May 2008 (UTC)
- Triforcel: Well, Shiek taught you the all important and incredibly useful warping songs. Plus they sound cool. Not sure what Tetra does as I've yet to play Wind Waker and she doesn't do much in Phantom Hourglass. Additionally, Ninjas > Pirates.
- Darklucario: Sheik is a ninja. She can throw needles incredibly fast, she can teleport, she has amazing speed. Tetra is a pirate, and has no special attacks or defences apart from a pirate ship. Sheik for the win!
- Wings Of Icarus 05:48, 9 May 2008 (UTC): Does Tetra use magic?
- Mario vs Bowser56 05:50, 9 May 2008 (UTC)
- User:Dark Ridley: Sheiks skills greatly outskill those of Tetra.
- sailormoonbeam02 sheik. hands down.
- User:Kperfekt722 06:31, 9 May 2008 (UTC) Tetra is a mere cartoon. Zelda is an animation :D
Anonymous votes Edit
- Shiek is obviously more skilled, and plus if Tetra did kill her, she herself would vanish....making it a draw. And plus Shiek is older than Tetra.
- No doubt about it. Shiek is older, smarter, and strongger than Tetra. Plus, Ocarina of Time is so much cooler than Wind Waker.
- Sheik knows kong-fu. Tetra knows how to insult Link badly. I wonder which one is stronger? Hmm, this is a tough one...
- Sheik, hands down. Not even a competition between them.
- As I said before, this is the classic Pirates vs Ninjas battle. I go for the ninja. Shiek is faster, stronger, and more intelligent
- Sheik will obviously win because Tetra turned to stone in the Phantom Hourglass, I don't think stones can fight..
- Shiek will win all out. Nintendo used her for Brawl. Tetra isn't there!!! Mrkmil
- Sheik can actually FIGHT. Where are Tetra is just....... Tetra
- I think that if you base it on age Sheik would win. Tetra doesn't seem to have as much experiance as Sheik, and Tetra also sees a bit childish at times.
- Sheik managed to survive as a fugitive in the realms of the enemy for seven long years, while Tetra was caught by Ganondorf long before the end of the game. Voted by Reogan.
- Sheik hands down. Her ablities to move quickly and silently can work wonders against the usual pirate tactics of charging with cutlasses drawn, hoping no one cuts them down before getting into cutting range.
- Sheik would be able to defeat Tetra easily. Shiek is more agile than Tetra, and and is also stronger. Also Tetra(in the Wind Waker) was easily captured by the big bird. Also Shiek is just cooler, and you can't tell that Shiek is Zelda, but you can tell from Tetra's hair that she is Zelda.
- Shiek is also seen in the Super Smash Brothers games while Tetra not. Finally Tetra needs her pirates to help her while Shiek is strong by his/her self.
|
Votes for Tetra Edit
- Though I like Ninjas and I like Sheik, Tetra's my favorite leading Zelda lady. Oath to Order 19:47, 7 May 2008 (UTC)
Anonymous votes Edit
- I believe that Tetra has a bigger chance of survival then shiek.
- At least we know for certain that Tetra is a girl
- First off, we never really see sheik actually fight. all she/he does is teach you a song, give you a few hints, and deku nut her way out before any fighting starts. don't get me wrong, i love all of her songs and her theme (sheik's theme is one of the best themes i've ever heard and the only reason my choice isn't a landslide), but if sheik were really that powerful, she would have helped link in some of his dungeons at least. On the other hand, Tetra leaped to link's aid and even faced down the king of darkness himself. Sheik/Zelda hid from Ganon for 7 years. Although Sheik was an amazing character in SSBM (so-so in SSBB), i'm pretty sure the smash games are non-canonical (you know a game is non-canonical when link can jump at will asides from ZeldaII. i'm missing another few games where he can actually jump at will but you get my point). all of her moves in the smash games are all based on how sheik might have fought if she actually did any fighting. Although Sheik would probably be a good fighter, until i see sheik actually throw a few punches (or needles. i don't remember needles in OoT) and have a little confirmation that zelda's disguise is more than just for show, i'll side with tetra.
-Response 5/13: (good job. nice to see some actual debating going on) Ganondorf was also actively looking for princess zelda in WW. Like in OoT, he employed a vast army of soldiers for the search. when tetra jumped in to help link during his confrontation with Ganondorf, she did it to save him. in OoT, sheik revealed her/himself as zelda for the sake of revealing who she was and was consequently caught. Tetra (as Zelda) is held in the Basement of Hyrule though she wanted to help link. She originally wanted to go, but was advised by the king not to in order to protect her and the triforce of wisdom. She even participates in Link's final battle with Ganondorf actually assisting with the fighting. Sheik nor Zelda from OoT do anything in their final battle, except when Zelda holds down Ganon for the finishing blow after Ganon was beaten to a pulp. if you compare the link/tetra confrontation with Ganondorf for the first time with the link/sheik Bongo Bongo fiasco, the outcome was pretty much the same for the 2 duos. you can say that means that tetra against Ganondorf fared equally with sheik vs Bongo which in turn can be interpreted as Tetra doing better in a battle against sheik (in some weird math equasion since Ganon>Bongo) by comparison. The OoT manga suggested that link may have had a thing for sheik which totally throws off my linkxsaria attitude so i try to keep the non-canon stuff from affecting my decisions:)
|
Peanut Gallery Edit
- In response to the anonymus person that is number 2 for Tetra, you forget several things, just a few of those being: 1) Sheik was the seventh Sage, someone that Ganondorf was actively looking for and would stop at nothing to find. How could Sheik really risk revealing herself as Zelda when that would have put the entire Triforce of Wisdom within his grasp? Tetra did not even possess the full Triforce of Wisdom until she met Daphnes Nohansen Hyrule at the bottom of the sea; 2) Tetra had no idea at that point who Ganondorf was or that she was even Zelda when she jumped at him to save Link, so what she was doing was more foolish than even she or yourself realize. Had she known just who Ganondorf really was or that he was specifically searching for her, she may not have been so keen to jump right into his path like Sheik. When she realized she was Zelda, she hid from Ganondorf at the bottom of the sea much like Sheik had done. So that point is kind of a moot one considering that she had no idea what was going on at that point; 3) We don't see Sheik fight in the temples as I said to keep her identity safely hidden from Ganondorf. She also did battle Bongo Bongo upon his escape from the well alongside Link, although they failed to stop it from entering the Shadow Temple. We also learn of Sheik being a more active fighter in the manga of OOT, and while it is not canon, it still suggests that Sheik is a fiercer fighter than meets the eye. So not all of your statements in support of Tetra are exactly valid when you consider the big picture. Hero of Time 87 22:06, 11 May 2008 (UTC)
That was the third vote, and i madde the first vote (i wasn't a member at the time). solar flute
|