| LLLLLLLLLLAAAAADDIIEEEESSSS AAANND GGEEEEENNTLLEMMEENNNNNN!!! Welcome to the 174th battle in our most excellent TEMPLE. OF. CCOOOOOOOOOOOUUUUUUUURRRRRRRAAAAAAAAAAAAGGGGGE! FINALLY, we see two more damsels in distress duke it out in a daring duel! Which dame will dominate? Let's find out who they are!
In the blue corner, we have someone close to our hero! This girl was taken from her home by the Helmaroc King, a monstrous bird that kidnaps girls with pointed ears. Desperate to save her, He sailed to the bird's nest, the Forsaken Fortress, where she was being held prisoner. After a long journey all around the world, here boy finally managed to rescue her! Please welcome the very reason he set off on his journey to defeat Ganondorf and save the Great Sea in the first place! THIS. IS. AAAAAAARRRRYYYYYYLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL!
In the peach corner is our hero's childhood friend! This horse-loving girl was kidnapped by King Bulblin and taken to Hyrule, leading the hero into the battle to reclaim Hyrule and banish the Twilight! She was imprisoned in the Hidden Village with Impaz, and somewhere along the way, she got amnesia. Her memory returned, however, and she aided mister hero in his quest! THIS. IS. IIIIIILLLLLLIIIIIIIIAAAAAAAA!
Without any further ado, LLLLLLLLLLLLLLEEEEET'S GET RRRRRREEEEEEEAAAAADYYYYYYY TOOO RRRRRRRRRRRRUUMMMMMMMMMBBLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLEEE!!!
|
Votes for Aryll Edit
- So Cute! Oni Dark Link 22:55, November 25, 2012 (UTC)
- Just a generally more likable character. Xykeb Yvolix Zraliv 01:13, November 26, 2012 (UTC)
- I found Ilia annoying. Actually I found all the kids in TP annoying. To me Ilia felt like a concept that had to be cut short and was left incomplete. I find myself cringing less with Aryll than Ilia, so Aryll gets my vote. IceFlame 08:02, November 26, 2012 (UTC)
- Aryll is just a better character. Green Rupee 15:37, November 26, 2012 (UTC)
- Aryll knows that it's better to give Link his item sooner rather than later. The Horse Call would have been more useful than the Telescope if it was given in the early-game, but as is, I got more use out of the Telescope. I don't think I used the Horse Call even once since the Twilight Portals were so much more efficient than riding Epona by that point. Aryll was also the more likeable character; I didn't particularly care for the hinted romance between Link and Ilia. Jedimasterlink (talk) 08:36, November 27, 2012 (UTC)
- I'm still scarred by link's creepy vision of Ilia falling in Lanayru's spring. --Hydropanda (talk) 01:55, November 29, 2012 (UTC)
- Haven't played Wind Walker, but Ilia was so annoying that every time I saw her I wanted to kill her (all attempts failed), so Ayrll gets my vote. User:Poe Busters
- My very first vote, I'm choosing Aryll because she's more of a supporting and courageous character than Ilia. Ilia's cool and all, but she doesn't have that adventurous spark Aryll has in her characteristics. --Vaati the Wind Demon (talk) 03:12, December 1, 2012 (UTC)
- Ilia getting captured was totally random. Aryll had a more inportant role in the game, you don't even have to get Ilia's memory back to beat the game, you can just let her stand in the sanctuary wondering who she is forever!(Hookshooter)
- Aryll is a lot more likable, plus she is not Ilia. ~Minish (talk) 13:35, December 8, 2012 (UTC)
- For the sole reason that she never took my horse. Ike 21:54, December 10, 2012 (UTC)
- Come on... Risking your life for some broad will never be has rewarding has saving your little sister's life!!! Aryll this one is for you...--Longhorn Velez (talk) 19:53, December 31, 2012 (UTC)
- Aryll is just adorable!! Without her Link would not have got caught up in the mess that he ended up in... Ilia just steals horses and forgets herself. TimboJimbo(talk) 11:21, January 22, 2013 (UTC)
- Aryll gives you a telescope, Llia steals your horse... not much of a contest there, in addition it's not how much i like aryll it's how much I dislike Llia for stealing stuff from me and making me go on boring quests. User:Majoras revenge!!! (User talk:Majoras revenge!!!)
- Much as I love Ilia, Aryll is just so endearing to me, and adorable. Plus, if not for her, I would never have set out in the first place. --NilkadNaqadah
Anonymous votes Edit
- While Ilia never gave me any motivation in TP (with characters like Colin, Midna and Zelda filling that void), I could feel the urgency in saving Aryll. She's a more developed character and, in my opinion, means more to the player in terms of rescue motivation.
- So cute !
- While I got more use out of the Horse Call than I did out of the Telescope, I still prefer Aryll. I can't put my finger on it, but I can remember Aryll more clearly. Probably because of a combination of her dresses (Ilia's clothes and hair are so...bland...) and her general role in the story.
- Ilia is ugly, Aryll is cute.
- I like Wind Waker better than Twilight Princess, and Ilia was a boring character anyway. And the telescope Aryll gives Link is VERY helpful for exploring each sector of the Great Sea entirely.
- Illa is annoying nuff said
- I've always liked Aryll's character. Wind Waker is quite nostalgic for me, as it's the first game I ever beat. The kid sister gets mah vote!
- I know a lot of people don't like Ilia for silly reasons, but as far as plot goes, I prefer the cute and sympathetic little sister to the one with the more and more common amnesia trip. Liked Ilia's character, both of who she was before and after she lost her memory, but Aryll always gave me more motivation to save her and the world. She's not only related to you, but she clearly cares about you more than Ilia did :P.
- Aryll! she's your lil' sister, and she is waaay cuter and has better hair than Illa.
- Aryll was a cute little girl with sweet seagull powers! Ilia was just...meh.
- I think that Aryll was awesome! As someone said earlier, it was a bit more urgent in saving her than when you had to go save Ilia. While Ilia might sort of be a love interest in the game, who would pass up the opportunity to save the cute little sister?
- This one was a toughie...but I have to go with Aryll because Ilia could get annoying in the beginning of the game, what with her taking your horse and yelling at you all the time. Plus, I like TWW as a whole a lot more than TP, and that includes Aryll over any other character. I was more motivated to save Aryll, in part because she was my sister and in part because, as stated above, Ilia was pretty annoying and never even apologized
- Aryll for the win.
- Love Windwaker, Love Aryll
- Truth to be told, I was more intent on finding cats than saving Ilia.
- Aryll!!!
- Aryll. Wind Waker. 'Nuff Said.
- Ilia's personality + forgetability = BORING!
- Aryll because I think Link having a sister was awesome and I found myself wanting to see more of her by the end of the game
- Aryll was pretty cool, and Link trying to protect her as her big brother was sweet. I love Toon Link and liked the idea of a Link with a family. Plus, Wind Waker was a much more lighthearted yet darker game than TP, story-wise. Also, Illia was just the childhood love interest with amnesia. Like we haven't heard THAT one before.
- I preferred Wind Waker, personally. She and Link had a really cute relationship, too. Plus she gave me that handy telescope, and was just a general sweetie.
- Talk about abandoned. This place is DEAD.
|
Votes for Ilia Edit
- Surprisingly, this is a very hard decision for me to make. While I absolutely adore both games, and prefer Aryll over Ilia, I have to go with Ilia. Something about her role in Twilight Princess, while it made me absolutely hate her, I really liked. Honestly, I'm still not sure why she gets kidnapped, and frankly, I hated having to find her. When it comes down to it, even though I prefer Aryll to Ilia, I'm gonna have to go with Ilia for reasons I don't even know. It just feels right, y'know? – Jazzi talk 21:48, November 25, 2012 (UTC)
- Always gotta vote for the underdog! : D Quite frankly, I disliked both characters in different ways -- though, I prolly disliked Ilia more, she did have a more prominent role throughout the game. – Wattz2000 18:16, November 26, 2012 (UTC)
- Love TP, Hate the "Toon Link" Games. Easy choice. I also actually like Ilia as a character, she is a lot like Zelda at the beginning of Skyward Sword in her relationship to Link. --Tiero (talk) 19:05, November 26, 2012 (UTC)
- Link and close siblings/relatives just doesn't work... at least, it hasn't, so far. While Ilia felt a bit too much like a footnote in the grand scheme of things, at least they made *something* out of making the rescue seem worthwhile. --AuronKaizer! 17:12, November 27, 2012 (UTC)
- Aryll is likeable enough, but Illia just had more of a story. It was a (fairly) interesting way to do a rescue scenario, at least moreso than Aryll's.-- C2 / CC 23:24, November 28, 2012 (UTC)
- Ilia catalyzed the story and had depth of character. She returned later on as a vital part of the plot instead of leaving halfway through and was part of Link's earning the Horse Call. Aryll just gave Link a reason to leave Outset Island. --Jarmihi (talk) 15:48, January 16, 2013 (UTC)
- While I hated Illia, I always hated Aryll more, since I always think of Link as an orphan, and him having a family doesn't work right for me.Geminis11(talk)
- Ilia was annoying, but she had a more developed character. She was more interesting than the alternative; Aryll was a virtual plot-device. (RadiantSoul)
- Ilia was way more interesting than Ayrll. Ilia wasn't some damsel in distress created for the sole purpose of that role, unlike Ayrll. (Link The Hero of Time)
- Ilia had a little more substance, though I think that was because she was pounded into my head during the three hour tutorial TP had going on. Also, she has more potential than Ayrll: the sister can only be a sister, while a childhood friend can be so much more. --IHaveNoIdea (talk) 12:45, April 23, 2013 (UTC)
Anonymous votes Edit
- Easy choice. She's a much better character, and has a larger role than just needing to be rescued.
- Uh.......
- I think since she actually HELPED Link, she should be chosen
- It was really close for me. I have never played Wind Waker, but I liked TP a lot, and although Aryll is Link's sister, I enjoyed Ilia as a character. She may have been really annoying and not as interesting as Colin, I fell like i should vote for her.
- This was a very strange decision for me. I liked Aryll, but you never really got to know her. Illia was(even though you knew her for an hour, max)a good friend. She gave your horse protection, for pete's sake. People are saying that the whole journey of Wind Waker started because of Aryll. I agree with that, but Illia and Link's friends are also the reason that Twilight Princess started. Heck, Ilia had took an arrow to the calf.
- I have to choose Ilia just because her story was more tragic and meaningful in Twilight Princess than Aryll's was in Windwaker. Even though I'm pissed at her for getting mad at Link for accidentally hurting Epona and being in the wrong place at the wrong time. But anyway, Ilia simply delivered more to the storyline in the end.
- Ilia actually helps Link out. Aryll really isn't present in the game that much.
- I prefer Ilia to Aryll, because she helps Link. For example giving him the Horse Call, which is really useful when you need Epona around. Her story makes more sense to the game's plot and is a part of it. Also Link cared for her all the time and in my opinion rescuing a dear friend touches me more than rescuing a sister. You can't replace friends and that's why I ended up giving my vote to Ilia.
- Basically just going with this, because I found the characterizaton in general deeper in TP.
- She seemed more fleshed out to me and I like Twilight Princess more in general
- 1. I don't like wind waker and 2. I have an annoying sister, so I'm sort of biased.
- Ilia, she had a more developed character and she and Link looked like they were really in love.
- Ilia actually helps Link. Aryll just can't do anything. It's like, "by the way your sister is randomly kidnapped." And Ilia plays a role in the game. And may I just say,Ilia is actually hot!
- Haven't played either, But she sounds cooler than the other one.
- Ilia because, as mentioned, her character is developed more and also, i love how kind she is to prince Ralis, how she is more concerned for some stranger of another species than she is for her own memory.
|
Peanut Gallery Edit
This reminds me strongly of a fight I came up with before I forgot my password and lost the email address for my account.
- Just out of curiosity, what was the fight? 23:48, November 26, 2012 (UTC)
- It was the kidnappers of these fine young ladies - Helmaroc King vs King Bulbin
- Had to tear through the archives to recall the details since it was over two years ago, but that was a good, close fight. Sorry to hear about your account. Since you won't be using the other one, you could always make a new account and use it without penalty. Jedimasterlink (talk) 08:59, November 27, 2012 (UTC)
I was gonna change the fight, but then I took an arrow to the calf? – Jazzi talk 18:06, December 14, 2012 (UTC)
Did everyone take an arrow in the calf?
- Yes, we did. More importantly, we haven't exactly gotten the introduction for the fight with the most supports so we weren't able to change it. And right now I can't change it due to some personal life events, but hopefully next week. – EnemyPeacemaker 13:54, February 17, 2013 (UTC)
Sorry, I never meant to sound rude or anything. Thanks for explaining, though.
- Oh, don't apologize, I didn't take it rudely! I probably came across as irritated, due to what was going on at that time, but I really hope you don't think I thought you were being rude. I was trying to continue the joke, but with what happened it was kind of bland. Anyways, I (hope) to get a new fight up this Sunday! – EnemyPeacemaker 21:09, February 22, 2013 (UTC)
I hope so too.
Um, how long is this fight going to be up? I don't want to sound like a jerk but this has been up pretty long. RedPelican (talk) 17:55, April 15, 2013 (UTC)
- Temple of Courage is actually on a hiatus. – EnemyPeacemaker 18:20, April 15, 2013 (UTC)
Oh, sorry. RedPelican (talk) 16:35, April 18, 2013 (UTC)
The Temple of Courage is on a hiatus till further notice You can continue to vote in this fight, but the rule where you don't vote in the previous fight is still in place. Please do not place further complaints about the fight not changing. It will be changed in time.
|